http://www.good.is/post/math-isn-t-just-computation-so-why-is-that-all-we-teach/
Check out the video on the page above. The man who created Wolfram Alpha - like wikipedia for mathematics - does a wonderful speech about how math isn't soley about computing. There are four things, he says, which makes up mathematics - and only one of them deals with manually completing problems. More importantly are asking the right questions and thinking correctly about how to solve those questions. He suggests that we tie in technology by having the students program computers to do the heavy computing work for us. Computers, after all, are quite often better at completing real-world mathematics problems then we are. It takes true understanding of a topic to program a computer to complete the problem.
I love this idea! My biggest - really, only - concern is access. I'm not sure if schools can afford programming technology. Woops, I lied. My second concern is the curricula. I think the "necessity" of testing (I don't really feel like standardized tests tell us the right things, but that's for another day) takes away the time needed for real learning of the material. It might take, like Wolfram says, a complete rewrite of the mathematics curriculum nation-wide. If this ever comes to light among the guys who can do this, I'm more than happy to be one of the beta testers.
Summaries and reactions to articles relating to the relation of technology and mathematics in education. This blog was started as a class assignment for Instructional Technology 444 at Western Washington University and continued as a beginning teacher.
Sunday, September 11, 2011
Multitasking in the Classroom
Excerpt from "The Student's Perspective" by Carie Windham:
"Filling the Attention Deficit: Reaching the Net Generation in a Traditional Classroom
In middle school, my second-period health class took a break from memorizing the food groups to learn healthy study habits. Flipping idly past images of red-shirted, blue-panted stick figures seated upright in desk chairs in our text, we were told that the best way to study was to isolate ourselves from the television, the tape player, and the busy sidewalks outside the window. We were to clear a nice study corner with a comfy chair, good lighting, and ample work space.
If Harcourt Brace were to evaluate my college study space, it would–no doubt–be the antithesis of healthy study habits pictured in one of their textbooks. There would be no clear desk, no silent cocoon, no harsh lighting. Instead, Law and Order reruns would be playing in the background. To my left, a trail of jumbled cords would stretch from my bedroom to a laptop on the couch cushion. My IM buddy list would be minimized on the screen, but noise alerts would be turned on to tell me when friends signed on or off the Internet. A collage of browser windows would remain open, one directed to CNN.com to read the day's news between chapters, another to my e-mail to know exactly when the next piece of mail arrived, and then another to Google, in case the text raised any questions. Somewhere in the middle would be me and a history textbook turned to page 149.
My study space-which could be found in the average dorm room suite-is characteristic of my life. With information and accessibility lying effortless at my fingertips, I have grown accustomed to juggling multiple tasks at once, at lightning speed. In the average online conversation with a friend, for instance, I am likely to be talking to two others, shopping online at Barnes & Noble, laughing out loud at Friends reruns, and printing off notes from a chemistry lecture. It is only in the classroom, therefore, that my mind is trained on one subject. To keep it in place requires some flexibility and creativity on the part of the professor and an understanding of the basic principles that guide the Net Generation"
I completely agree with this snapshot of college dorm rooms during study time. It was hard for me to focus in any environment but, ironically, I found it harder to study in an environment without distractions. In schools we are expected to sit still and pay attention to one person. The way I see it, if 1 of my 5 senses are occupied, the others get jealous and distract the original sense. That is, if a professor is lecturing (and only lecturing) then my eyes need something so keep it busy. I've been in more than one lecture class while playing a game on my phone. Even though it looks like I'm not paying attention, I'm actually paying attention better than when I'm just staring at the professor. I'm not sure how to explain this to someone who didn't grow up this way, including my professors.
"Filling the Attention Deficit: Reaching the Net Generation in a Traditional Classroom
In middle school, my second-period health class took a break from memorizing the food groups to learn healthy study habits. Flipping idly past images of red-shirted, blue-panted stick figures seated upright in desk chairs in our text, we were told that the best way to study was to isolate ourselves from the television, the tape player, and the busy sidewalks outside the window. We were to clear a nice study corner with a comfy chair, good lighting, and ample work space.
If Harcourt Brace were to evaluate my college study space, it would–no doubt–be the antithesis of healthy study habits pictured in one of their textbooks. There would be no clear desk, no silent cocoon, no harsh lighting. Instead, Law and Order reruns would be playing in the background. To my left, a trail of jumbled cords would stretch from my bedroom to a laptop on the couch cushion. My IM buddy list would be minimized on the screen, but noise alerts would be turned on to tell me when friends signed on or off the Internet. A collage of browser windows would remain open, one directed to CNN.com to read the day's news between chapters, another to my e-mail to know exactly when the next piece of mail arrived, and then another to Google, in case the text raised any questions. Somewhere in the middle would be me and a history textbook turned to page 149.
My study space-which could be found in the average dorm room suite-is characteristic of my life. With information and accessibility lying effortless at my fingertips, I have grown accustomed to juggling multiple tasks at once, at lightning speed. In the average online conversation with a friend, for instance, I am likely to be talking to two others, shopping online at Barnes & Noble, laughing out loud at Friends reruns, and printing off notes from a chemistry lecture. It is only in the classroom, therefore, that my mind is trained on one subject. To keep it in place requires some flexibility and creativity on the part of the professor and an understanding of the basic principles that guide the Net Generation"
I completely agree with this snapshot of college dorm rooms during study time. It was hard for me to focus in any environment but, ironically, I found it harder to study in an environment without distractions. In schools we are expected to sit still and pay attention to one person. The way I see it, if 1 of my 5 senses are occupied, the others get jealous and distract the original sense. That is, if a professor is lecturing (and only lecturing) then my eyes need something so keep it busy. I've been in more than one lecture class while playing a game on my phone. Even though it looks like I'm not paying attention, I'm actually paying attention better than when I'm just staring at the professor. I'm not sure how to explain this to someone who didn't grow up this way, including my professors.
Thursday, June 9, 2011
Changing Education Paradigms
If the video does not load, you can find it here: http://myweb.wwu.edu/willarg/RSAnimate.mp4.
A full transcript of the speech can be found here: http://dotsub.com/view/b3bb5a92-6770-4962-ad76-4be0d643553f/viewTranscript/eng
Source: Sir Ken Robinson. "Changing Education Paradigms." RSA Animate. YouTube. Web. 10 June 2011. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zDZFcDGpL4U.
Summary: This article is actually a speech by Sir Ken Robinson, but I find it quite relevant and wanted to share. Sir Ken Robinson says that "Our children are living in the most intensely stimulating period in the history of the earth. They're being besieged with information that demand their attention on every platform... computers, from iPhones, from advertising hoardings, from hundreds of television channels.. and being penalized for getting distracted.. from boring stuff, in school mostly." He says that "our current system of education was conceived in the enlightenment and the economic circumstance of the industrial revolution" and that it should change, since today's society is based off of collaboration. He shares a longitudinal study done that shows how kindergartners lose their creative, divergent thinking by 10th grade. "the most important thing that has happened to them I am convinced now is they have become educated. They've spent 10 years at school, where they say 'there's one answer and it's at the back. And don't look! And don't copy, because that's cheating.' ...but outside school that is called collaboration."
Reaction: I agree that schools need to be changed to a collaborative environment, rather than a 'sit-in-rows', 'don't-leave-til-the-bell-rings' kind of system. However, the relevant thing to this technology blog is the part where he points out that today's students are multi-taskers but are forced to sit still in classrooms. When students are so 'plugged in' to their virtual worlds, including phones, Facebook, music, and games, and we ask them to unplug and focus on one (not generally stimulating) person in front of the room, of course they aren't going to be able to pay attention. At the very least, we should let them busy their hands (by playing a game on their phone) so they can pay attention by listening during a boring lecture. Optimally, students should have the freedom to multitask the way they do best. And who knows; maybe they learn more from their virtual environment then they do from us?
Social Networking - And Beyond!
Please click here to access my summary and reaction to this article, or go to http://myweb.wwu.edu/willarg/buildinglearningcommunities.wma. I have included a transcript of my summary below.
Summary: This article talks about meeting students at their level by using Facebook as a teacher. It recognizes the use of having a group for the class but warns that the connection cannot be purely social. The connection is not broken at 3:00 and teachers must be willing to maintain a constant online presence. It also recognizes that students today are used to multitasking (as I type this, listen to music, and watch my roommate play on the xbox) and can handle items from multiple sources. Using Facebook, a teacher can create a community within - and abroad from - the classroom. This is conductive to a collaborative learning process.
Reaction: I was primarily curious on the graph above and how it will change in time, when the "digital natives" (see previous article) grow up and take the place of the "digital immigrants". I, as a digital native, completely agree with the idea of using Facebook to create a classroom community in which I am completely reachable to the students and so they can connect to one another. One obstacle would be overcoming the parent's fears of internet safety if their children do not already have a Facebook. Another potential issue might be student access to the internet. A community is only effective if all members can take part.
Source: 07/22/09, Ruth Reynard. "Beyond Social Networking: Building Toward Learning Communities -- Campus Technology." Campus Enterprise Networking & Infrastructure -- Campus Technology. Web. 10 June 2011. http://campustechnology.com/articles/2009/07/22/beyond-social-networking-building-toward-learning-communities.aspx.
| Chart from article |
Reaction: I was primarily curious on the graph above and how it will change in time, when the "digital natives" (see previous article) grow up and take the place of the "digital immigrants". I, as a digital native, completely agree with the idea of using Facebook to create a classroom community in which I am completely reachable to the students and so they can connect to one another. One obstacle would be overcoming the parent's fears of internet safety if their children do not already have a Facebook. Another potential issue might be student access to the internet. A community is only effective if all members can take part.
Source: 07/22/09, Ruth Reynard. "Beyond Social Networking: Building Toward Learning Communities -- Campus Technology." Campus Enterprise Networking & Infrastructure -- Campus Technology. Web. 10 June 2011. http://campustechnology.com/articles/2009/07/22/beyond-social-networking-building-toward-learning-communities.aspx.
Web 2.0 | Beyond Google
Summary: This article explains ways that you can use the internet to learn, beyond Google and Wikipedia. One teacher uses blogs and wikis to give the students a new audience and a paperless geography class. An elementary school teacher had their students describe the favorite part of summer with pictures and put them together. "It was just amazing what our young students could do, if we gave it to them in digestible pieces and let them explore." Other teachers use Facebook and LinkedIn to teach their students about professional online identities. Video games are another Web2.0 tool. It also has a list of websites at the bottom that are worth checking out.
Reaction: This article, although generally obvious to me (as a digital native), make me think about ways to incorporate games into my classroom. For example, there is an online game called Pandemicm(www.crazymonkeygames.com/Pandemic-2.html) which allows the player to create a virus, bacteria, or parasite, choose it's traits, and release it in the country of their choice. The object of the game is to infect as many people as possible. Although this sounds morbid, it contains a real example of exponential functions, with the effectiveness of the disease's ability to travel directly related to the steepness of the function.
Source:
Reaction: This article, although generally obvious to me (as a digital native), make me think about ways to incorporate games into my classroom. For example, there is an online game called Pandemicm(www.crazymonkeygames.com/Pandemic-2.html) which allows the player to create a virus, bacteria, or parasite, choose it's traits, and release it in the country of their choice. The object of the game is to infect as many people as possible. Although this sounds morbid, it contains a real example of exponential functions, with the effectiveness of the disease's ability to travel directly related to the steepness of the function.
Source:
Curwood, Jen Scott. "Web 2.0: Beyond Google | Scholastic.com." Teaching Resources, Children's Book Recommendations, and Student Activities | Scholastic.com. Web. 09 June 2011. http://www2.scholastic.com/browse/article.jsp?id=3753598.
Tech "gURLs"
Summary: Tech gURLs: closing the Technological Gender Gap is about overcoming the gender difference in technology. The IGNITE (inspiring girls now in technology evolution) program in Seattle is working toward giving girls role models and service projects in technology. Since the beginning of the program, the enrollment in technology classes has increased from 5% to 40-60% in 9 years. It says that "although boys often embrace new challenges or tools just for the sake of doing so, girls generally prefer to put what they're learning in context." The program shows girls ways that 'female dominated' fields, such as writing or artistry, are involved in technological jobs, such as technical writer or computer animation.
Reaction: I think this applies to math as well as technology, especially as math is integral in technology. I really agree that girls need positive role models in feilds that require math. I also agree that service projects would help them see the real world in a mathematical light. I think that it is a good idea to give students - boys and girls alike - the chance to see the things they like in math, such as proof (argument) and algebra (logic/puzzles).
Source: http://www.edutopia.org/computer-science-technology-gender-gap
Reaction: I think this applies to math as well as technology, especially as math is integral in technology. I really agree that girls need positive role models in feilds that require math. I also agree that service projects would help them see the real world in a mathematical light. I think that it is a good idea to give students - boys and girls alike - the chance to see the things they like in math, such as proof (argument) and algebra (logic/puzzles).
Source: http://www.edutopia.org/computer-science-technology-gender-gap
Wednesday, June 8, 2011
Give Girls A Chance
Summary: Give Girls a Chance: Building a Bridge to Science and Technology is an article about the Techbridge program in Oakland, California. 2000 girls participated in a city-wide program designed to offer hands-on science. It points out that "we face a classroom situation that in many ways seems stuck in time, even as the technology itself races ahead." These girls who are given a more hands-on approach to science are more interested and motivated because they are in charge of their own learning and are less worried about conforming to gender roles. They also started becoming more self-confident and speaking up more often in class. They would take time in class to talk about school and support one another with grades. "It's not cool to be a girl and smart in this school. But it is in Techbridge."
Response: I really like this article. It shows that when students are in charge of their own learning, taught relevant things, and supported, they will succeed. Even though this is specifically aimed at science, I beleive it is perfectly applicable in a mathematics classroom. Actually, all students (no matter what content area) could benefit from this class. I don't think it takes a special, seperate, program to give this to the students. Any effective teacher could give the students a relevant, interesting topic and support for the rest of their classes.
Source:
Response: I really like this article. It shows that when students are in charge of their own learning, taught relevant things, and supported, they will succeed. Even though this is specifically aimed at science, I beleive it is perfectly applicable in a mathematics classroom. Actually, all students (no matter what content area) could benefit from this class. I don't think it takes a special, seperate, program to give this to the students. Any effective teacher could give the students a relevant, interesting topic and support for the rest of their classes.
Source:
Furger, Roberta. "Give Girls a Chance: Building a Bridge to Science and Technology | Edutopia." K-12 Education & Learning Innovations with Proven Strategies That Work | Edutopia. Edutopia, 3 Sept. 2003. Web. 08 June 2011. http://www.edutopia.org/techbridge-science-technology-girls.
Monday, June 6, 2011
Learning Geometry Without A Protractor
Summary: This article explains the research done with the MundurucĂș in the Amazon. A group of adults and children are asked questions about Euclidean Geometry and were able to quickly grasp concepts. The group actually succeeded as well as similar ages from France and the United States. This shows that geometry might be a little more universal than is generally thought. A group of 5 and 6 year old American children did poorly on the test, however, showing that there may be a point at which the ideas emerge and become innate. Studies are still going on.
Reflection: I, as a future math teacher, agree that geometry is an innate subject as it is all around us. The top two complaints I hear about geometry in the middle and high schools have to do with proof and constructions. Students don't see how those things relate to their lives, even if they are obvious to teachers and mathematicians. I chose this article because it implies that students don't need fancy computer programs or tools to learn geometry.
Source: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/24/science/24obgeometry.html?_r=2&ref=science
Bhanoo, Sindya N. "Learning Geometry Without a Protractor." The New York Times. 23 May 2011. Web. 6 June 2011.
Reflection: I, as a future math teacher, agree that geometry is an innate subject as it is all around us. The top two complaints I hear about geometry in the middle and high schools have to do with proof and constructions. Students don't see how those things relate to their lives, even if they are obvious to teachers and mathematicians. I chose this article because it implies that students don't need fancy computer programs or tools to learn geometry.
Source: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/24/science/24obgeometry.html?_r=2&ref=science
Bhanoo, Sindya N. "Learning Geometry Without a Protractor." The New York Times. 23 May 2011. Web. 6 June 2011.
Sunday, April 17, 2011
Digital Natives and Immigrants
Summary:
Marc Prensky argues that students of all ages have permanently evolved into the digital generation. He calls them “Digital Natives”, and the older generation, “Digital Immigrants.” Using this analogy, he points out that immigrants of a new language or culture, especially older individuals, have a hard time learning the new ways and almost always keep an ‘accent’ of their previous language. The digital natives are a generation of instant gratification and constant input. They are constantly ‘plugged in’ and actively resist schools since they are asked to ‘power down’, sit still, and pay attention to one person. The immigrants are used to studiously working through school, reading textbooks, learning, memorizing, and regurgitating information onto tests. They can’t imagine their students learning while watching TV or listening to music because they can’t do it. Prensky argues that the natives have completely been rewired for the technology generation, watching Sesame Street to learn, looking things up on the internet rather than in a dictionary, emailing and instant messaging instead of talking face to face. He states that educators should teach the generation the way they learn best – by giving them games. It’s much easier for the immigrants to ‘evolve’ than the natives to go back to the old ways.
Response:
This article was written in 2001 and is already outdated. For instance, instant messaging is an old term. Today, we ‘tweet’ and ‘Facebook chat’. As a student of this generation, I feel prepared to teach students to come. One of my biggest concerns that I had to overcome to feel this way was the fact that technology is constantly changing. Over half of the jobs today did not exist when I started school. Watching the older individuals of my family, especially my grandmother, struggle with the introduction of technology, I was worried that the next technology would stump me and I would be stuck in the past as well. However, I have come to realize that part of being a ‘native’ is being flexible and adaptive. Each new technological advance has easily fit into my life. I agree wholeheartedly that we should teach to the new generation, but all that is going to change now since that generation is graduating teachers. There was a small evolutionary gap between the immigrants and the natives but we have worked through that in the last decade. I’m ready to teach the technology generation because I am part of it. Step aside, please, and let us change the world.
Reference:
Prensky, Marc. (10/2001). Digital Natives, Digital Immigrants. On the Horizon Vol. 9 No. 5. Retrieved from http://www.twitchspeed.com/site/Prensky%20-%20Digital%20Natives,%20Digital%20Immigrants%20-%20Part1.htm
Sunday, April 3, 2011
The Backwards Class
Summary:
![]() |
| From page two of the article |
Stacey Roshan, a beginner teacher in Maryland, has flipped her AP Calculus class upside-down. She has used technology to add her voice and pen to a PowerPoint presentation and posts the lecture online for her students to access. Their 'homework' is to watch the lectures. This leaves class time to work on homework. Students are allowed to work in groups and have the opportunity to ask their teacher clarifying questions. With this being the only change of her class, she feels the 3% grade increase was due to this new method. She is hoping to expand this technique to her other classes, including Algebra 1 and “traditional” (non-AP) Calculus.
Response:
At first glance, this is a great idea. However, looking at deeper glance at the school shows that it is higher-end. She says that most of her students have their laptops with them and looking at a picture of the students shows them in uniform. This tells me that I may not be able to use this technique in other schools where technology is not readily available at home. The article states that “this class [technique] can be used with or without computers or other smart devices” but I am not sure how. The main method of communication that Mrs. Roshan uses is completely based on technology. Her students have to access her lectures online. If a student has no access to technology, this method will not work. Also, students must be motivated to watch the 30 minute lecture outside of class.
Reference:
Schaffhauser, Dian. (2/2/2011). The Backwards Class. THE Journal: Transforming Education Through Technology. Retrieved from http://thejournal.com/Articles/2011/02/02/The-Backwards-Class.aspx?Page=1.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
