Sunday, September 11, 2011

Not Just Computation

http://www.good.is/post/math-isn-t-just-computation-so-why-is-that-all-we-teach/

Check out the video on the page above.  The man who created Wolfram Alpha - like wikipedia for mathematics - does a wonderful speech about how math isn't soley about computing.  There are four things, he says, which makes up mathematics - and only one of them deals with manually completing problems.  More importantly are asking the right questions and thinking correctly about how to solve those questions.  He suggests that we tie in technology by having the students program computers to do the heavy computing work for us.  Computers, after all, are quite often better at completing real-world mathematics problems then we are.  It takes true understanding of a topic to program a computer to complete the problem. 
I love this idea!  My biggest - really, only - concern is access.  I'm not sure if schools can afford programming technology.  Woops, I lied.  My second concern is the curricula.  I think the "necessity"  of testing (I don't really feel like standardized tests tell us the right things, but that's for another day) takes away the time needed for real learning of the material.  It might take, like Wolfram says, a complete rewrite of the mathematics curriculum nation-wide.  If this ever comes to light among the guys who can do this, I'm more than happy to be one of the beta testers. 

Multitasking in the Classroom

Excerpt from "The Student's Perspective" by Carie Windham:
"Filling the Attention Deficit: Reaching the Net Generation in a Traditional Classroom
In middle school, my second-period health class took a break from memorizing the food groups to learn healthy study habits. Flipping idly past images of red-shirted, blue-panted stick figures seated upright in desk chairs in our text, we were told that the best way to study was to isolate ourselves from the television, the tape player, and the busy sidewalks outside the window. We were to clear a nice study corner with a comfy chair, good lighting, and ample work space.
If Harcourt Brace were to evaluate my college study space, it would–no doubt–be the antithesis of healthy study habits pictured in one of their textbooks. There would be no clear desk, no silent cocoon, no harsh lighting. Instead, Law and Order reruns would be playing in the background. To my left, a trail of jumbled cords would stretch from my bedroom to a laptop on the couch cushion. My IM buddy list would be minimized on the screen, but noise alerts would be turned on to tell me when friends signed on or off the Internet. A collage of browser windows would remain open, one directed to CNN.com to read the day's news between chapters, another to my e-mail to know exactly when the next piece of mail arrived, and then another to Google, in case the text raised any questions. Somewhere in the middle would be me and a history textbook turned to page 149.
My study space-which could be found in the average dorm room suite-is characteristic of my life. With information and accessibility lying effortless at my fingertips, I have grown accustomed to juggling multiple tasks at once, at lightning speed. In the average online conversation with a friend, for instance, I am likely to be talking to two others, shopping online at Barnes & Noble, laughing out loud at Friends reruns, and printing off notes from a chemistry lecture. It is only in the classroom, therefore, that my mind is trained on one subject. To keep it in place requires some flexibility and creativity on the part of the professor and an understanding of the basic principles that guide the Net Generation"

I completely agree with this snapshot of college dorm rooms during study time.  It was hard for me to focus in any environment but, ironically, I found it harder to study in an environment without distractions.  In schools we are expected to sit still and pay attention to one person.  The way I see it, if 1 of my 5 senses are occupied, the others get jealous and distract the original sense.  That is, if a professor is lecturing (and only lecturing) then my eyes need something so keep it busy.  I've been in more than one lecture class while playing a game on my phone.  Even though it looks like I'm not paying attention, I'm actually paying attention better than when I'm just staring at the professor.  I'm not sure how to explain this to someone who didn't grow up this way, including my professors.